Last updated: 25 July 2004
Sent: Saturday, July 24, 2004 11:03:11 From: Jim Beston (firstname.lastname@example.org) You may remember I mailed you on June 25th concerning a broken ETX 105 alt/az gearbox. At the time I was able to keep the 'scope functioning well enough (a bit of "slack" in the movement though!) by using a cable clip to keep the final drive shaft located in it's "ring cradle" which had broken. My Meade supplier, Luigi Papagno. of www.f1cameras.com kindly obtained a new gearbox for me (under the warranty) and I would now like to install it. I looks quite straight forward but I just thought I'd ask if you knew of any pitfalls that I might encounter? I realise that I will have to calibrate & train the drives and check the persentage settings. Will there be any need to do a full reset? Thanks & Regards JimMike here: You shouldn't need to reset; just CALIBRATE and TRAIN DRIVES. As to replacing the gearbox, did they supply instructions? I'm surprised that Meade supplied that part under warranty!
No Mike, no instructions - I guess I'll see if it is as straight forward as I think to replace it! I've spent quite a bit of money on my 105 - accessories and the like. So I reckon I deserve a bit of luck on the warranty. Regards JimMike here: Warranty repairs that are not easily installed would normally be done by Meade. Replacing the Right Tube Adapter is simple but messing with the guts inside the base are a lot more error prone (like breaking wires). There are some articles on the Telescope Tech Tips page that could help if you want to try it.
I have already picked up some useful info. from "Tech. Tips" I'll let you know how I get on! JimAnd an update:
I replaced my ETX 105 alt/az gearbox and motor today - not entirely without incident but now all is working O.K. -so far!! I thought I would give an account of the replacement just in case it is of benifit to others: Removal: Really no problem at all 3 screws hold the gearbox to the base 3 more hold the worm drive assembly to the base - tight in its housing but "wiggled" out O.K. Two smaller screws hold the circuit board to the gearbox - although I removed these before withdrawing the gearbox, it would be better to leave them as the board and box can be withdrawn as a unit and the board more easily separated when the unit is out of the case. I noted the way round the two electrical connectors were, although it may not be possible to reverse them on reassembly. The unit was out in about 5 minutes and I thought I'd have the whole job done in half an hour..... Replacement .......However, I noted that the actual worm section on the worm drive on the new box (see photo) occupied more of the brass shaft than the old worm. No real consequence you may think but it meant that the screws that held the old worm assembly would not now squeeze past the shaft and into the two holes in its yoke because the "extended worm" was in the way. The obvious action was to remove the worm from the yoke, put the screws in and replace the worm. Easier said than done. I reckon a Mexican Assembler with the muscles of Superman must have tightened up the nut at the end of the worm drive. I hadn't access to a pair of self-locking pointed pliers, to hold the shaft, and I could not shift this nut without risk of injury to myself or (worse) the new unit!
Plan B swung smoothly into action - two flats were ground into opposite sides of the two screw-heads which just enabled them to slip passed the worm and into the holes on the yoke. Straight-forward after that - except that when I had fixed the whole assembly into the ETX base I noticed two "O" rings of abouut 3-4 mm i.d.sitting in the ETX base. (By the way it is a good idea to put some tissue into the bottom of the base as it lies on its side to prevent little screws dissapearing into the nether regions of the case - a pair of tweasers is useful in retreving such screws). I could not remember seeing these "O" rings during dissassembly, but they were the size of the two screws that hold the circuit board to the gearbox. Since I had not noted them between the screw head and the board, I reasoned that they must go between the board and the base. So off came the box and board to insert them. On replaceing the unit and powering up I was dismayed to find that the whole alt/az gear train was very stiff compared to how the old unit was. I rembered advice from Dr Sherord that the nut at the end of the worm drive was somtimes tightened too much at the Factory - of course this was the nut I couldn't shift!! I took the unit out (again) and held the shaft of the worm in a pair of pointed pliers and clamped the handles of the pliers in a large vise (vice). By tightening the vise I was able to get enough of a grip on the shaft to loosen the nut - about 1/4 turn seemed appropriate! Back went the unit and when powering up I found that the gears wouln't move at all! This is where I learnt the importance of tightening the gearbox assembly down evenly and (presumably) flush with the base. If you don't the gears lock or make a racket as though (probably the large thin one) is catching on something - ther must be a very small clearance somewhere. Having secured the box properly, I proceeded to do the usual calibrate and train routine. In addition it was necessary to check the percentage settings using the method of Dr Sherrod as described, in his mail to your site, of Dec. 12 2001. The Dec/RA, could be left at zero percent but the ALT/AZ required setting at 80% to remove backlash and allow a smooth movement. Although all now seems O.K., I have noted that to manually rotate the scope in ALT/AZ with the clutch disengaged, requires considerably more effort than before - although not excessively so. In addition I find that on slewing right or left in ALT/AZ at moderate speeds (3) there is a definite, but again not excessive, acceleration as the object moves across the field of view. Maybe the new box/motor requires "running in". Anyway I'm a Happy Bunny - I just hope I remain that way!! Kindest Regards Jim
Return to the top of this page.
Go back to the Tech Tips page.
Go back to the ETX Home Page.